$5,500,000
Single Family
2064 RIVER Road
Cayuga
4 Beds
3 Baths
5,572 sqft
Local Cayuga Realtor
Cayuga Ontario Homes for Sale and Local Realtor
Looking for homes for sale in Cayuga, Ontario? Jake Laracy is a REALTOR® with Pay It Forward Realty serving Cayuga and Haldimand County. Browse live MLS listings below or request a free home evaluation.
Cayuga Market Snapshot · Live MLS listings · Board benchmark pricing
28
Active Listings
$642,000
Benchmark Price
$642,000
Composite HPI
21
Avg Days on Market
Benchmark pricing based on Haldimand County benchmark pricing, from the Cornerstone Association of REALTORS®, August 2026 (source)
On the map
Homes for Sale in Cayuga
28 active MLS listings in Cayuga and surrounding cities. Click a marker for details.
Loading map...
$1,699,900
Single Family
655 TOWNLINE Road W
Cayuga
3 Beds
2 Baths
2,028 sqft
$1,599,900
Single Family
1140 RIVER Road
Cayuga
3 Beds
3 Baths
4,109 sqft
$1,049,900
Single Family
1300 RIVER Road
Cayuga
3 Beds
2 Baths
1,472 sqft
$999,000
Single Family
147 CONCESSION 1 Road S
Cayuga
4 Beds
2 Baths
1,501 sqft
$899,900
Single Family
55 MONTURE Street N
Cayuga
6 Beds
4 Baths
3,240 sqft
The area
About Cayuga
Cayuga is the county seat of Haldimand County and sits on the Grand River where Highway 3 and Highway 54 meet. It was incorporated as a village in 1859, and the county's administration office is still there.
Highway 54 follows the Grand River Valley from Brantford to Cayuga and winds along the river, so allow extra time compared with a straight highway. Cayuga is about 10 km east of Caledonia. A flood on February 13, 2009 damaged parts of the town, so ask about flood risk on any riverside property.
Public schools are run by the Grand Erie District School Board and Catholic schools by the Brant Haldimand Norfolk Catholic District School Board. Confirm the assigned school for a specific address.
Local guides
Your agent
Why Buy or Sell in Cayuga with Jake Laracy
Jake was born and raised in Brantford and has worked in real estate here for more than five years. Buyers get honest pros and cons before an offer is written. Sellers get a pricing plan based on current comparable sales, professional photography and a marketing plan. Jake works with Pay It Forward Realty, a brokerage built around giving back to local community causes. Call him at 226-934-4061 or request a free home evaluation.
- Born and raised in Brantford, with more than five years in local real estate and knowledge of Cayuga.
- Plain-English guidance through offers, inspections and closing.
- Pay It Forward Realty is built around giving back to local community causes.
Questions
Cayuga Real Estate FAQ
What is the average home price in Cayuga?
The MLS® Home Price Index benchmark price in Cayuga is $642,000 (based on Haldimand County benchmark pricing), according to the Cornerstone Association of REALTORS®, August 2026. There are currently 28 active MLS listings in Cayuga and the surrounding area. Prices vary a lot by neighbourhood and property type, so treat the benchmark as a starting point and ask Jake for recent sales near the home you are considering.
How long do homes take to sell in Cayuga?
Cayuga homes are currently averaging about 21 days on market based on live MLS data. Time on market depends on price, condition and season. Ask Jake for comparable sales in the neighbourhood you are looking at.
Is Cayuga a good place to buy in 2026?
Cayuga suits buyers who want a quiet Grand River community with a small-town feel, further from the city. Whether it is right for you depends on your budget and commute. Check the live benchmark price and listings above and ask Jake about specific properties.
Ready to Make Your Move in Cayuga?
Browse current listings or get a free, no-obligation home evaluation from Jake.
Explore Nearby Areas and Helpful Reading
Get In Touch
Ready to find your perfect home? I'm here to help you navigate the Brant, Haldimand, and Norfolk real estate market.
Send Me a Message
Phone
1-226-934-4061
laracy@payitforwardrealty.ca
Pay It Forward Realty Office
245 Brant Avenue
Brantford, Ontario N3T 3J4
Market Insights
Read the latest Brantford real estate market updates and local analysis